Hooker debate

No, he's been a stand out early and one of the few players putting in.

The scapegoating of him is very misguided.
 
I wouldn't touch one with my worst enemy's dick but I can see they serve a purpose..... Wait, what ?
 
Should have signed Segeyaro, now there's a guy who can turn a game on it's head.
 
And do what instead? He's an average hooker who lacks what it takes to be elite, but it's hardly like he's standing in the way of somebody young or is taking up big cap space that we could otherwise be using.
 
Buying another hooker is the last thing we need.

Segs is a fun player to watch, but a lot of his decision making leaves a lot to be desired.

Macca needs better support from his bench, Hunt should be developing his skills as a half, not a hooker and we should be using either Granville or Baptiste off the bench and exploiting their running game around tired legs.
 
Usually quite good, like last week when he forced that repeat set.

The only qualm is that sometimes he backs himself close to the line when nothing is doing.

Not a whole lot he could do last night really. He'd create space for his halves and both of them would get sacked and completely kill whatever momentum he had created.
 
His decision making is the worst in the league. He's the fcken slowest as well
 
Macca is not our problem. I wish we could focus on what this teams real problems are, instead of focusing on dumping players people would prefer their q cup buddies getting a run for.

Macca is not the best hooker going around but he is very solid and you can see the difference when he is off the field, replacing him with Baptiste or Granville or whoever will solve nothing.

Exaggerated comments like 'his decision making is the worst in the league' achieves nothing and adds nothing to a discussion because it simply isn't true and just highlights bias
 
Make no mistake, I've never been a huge Macca fan and am still not but he's ok. Well he's one of the less-average players in our team, actually I think he'd do well in a better team.

Right now we have Wallace who tries hard but isn't good enough, Prince who looks too old, fullback(s) who are amongst the worse in the game, a centre who's too slow and a forward pack that's not used in the right way and plenty of players who have been out of form for way too long.
 
New Posts

Unread

Active Now

No members online now.
Total: 126 (members: 0, guests: 126)
Top