Reply to thread

Message: [QUOTE="McHunt, post: 3445371, member: 9853"] When Selwyn is hot, he's red hot, but he's still finding his feet. He slips over, makes too many errors, and looks like he needs a little longer to ripen. And his defensive techniques look awkward at times. In my opinion, he's a little bit ahead of Ezra in securing a full time NRL position, but this question is about choosing the best of the best in the competition, and again, in my opinion, experience counts at the top level. The same argument applies to players like Suaali and Nanai but, regardless of age, they both look more mature than Selwyn right now. Well that's my opinion, anyway. But others here strongly disagree. Selwyn got picked in Origin because he was literally flavour of the month, and really only that month. Only a handful of games before that the same commentators were suggesting he needed some time in the QLD Cup. In my opinion, he needed more time in the NRL before making the step up. Many will disagree, but he returned from Origin injured both physically and mentally. There's no question in my mind he should've been left on the vine another year. [/QUOTE]

No members online now.

Total: 266 (members: 0, guests: 266)