Reply to thread

Message: [QUOTE="Jaybronq, post: 2963582, member: 9304"] When they vote on an immortal, anything off field is not considered at all. they vote only on playing ability on the field nothing done off-field matters, cause they dont use that in the criteria to vote, winning 8 origins and all that mal did doesnt matter the only thing that matters is his playing ability on the field. And when that is taking into account with the other players he up against i dont think he measures up. Compared against lockyer... there is no comparison in terms of playing ability, stats dont even matter everyone keeps talking about stats and they did this on-field and off. PLaying ability wise Lockyer is ahead of meninga, Lockyer should get it not mal. mal was great but he isnt an immortal, gene miles was better than meninga on the field. The 2 who should get it is, Lockyer & messenger or Lockyer & Provin in terms of playing ability hes ahead of the rest and if he doesnt get it, then this is the same as a political election... the fact todd greenburg is on the judging panel is very concerning. [/QUOTE]

No members online now.

Total: 145 (members: 0, guests: 145)