Reply to thread

Message: [QUOTE="Hamm.0, post: 2185394, member: 1852"] Great idea NNN, a few of us have discussed this on MSN, would be brilliant to see it actually happen. I'd definitely vote, however may I make some suggestions? - Firstly, I think it would be a good idea to select a "judging panel" who are the actual judges week in, week out. This is not an elitist thing and anyone you decide/anyone who volunteers can be on the panel. I dare to suggest there is at least 20 regular BHQites who [size=7](think they)[/size] have a decent grasp of the game. The reason for this is it stops posters blowing in, giving 3 points to Elia and blowing out again...LOLZ, besides that obvious slander, what it achieves is stopping agendas forming during the season (e.g. De Vere has a defensive blinder, stops 3 tries however because he isn't flashy and isn't 18, people don't vote for him because they feel he shouldn't be in the team ahead of other players). The same people who are keen enough to be a part of the panel, will be fairly honest throughout the season, therefore the judging is somewhat standardised. - Secondly, if a member of the judging panel misses a week, simply no points taken in from that judge, which won't effect the standard of the judging for that week (sounds simple, yet many forums that have things like this try and give absent points to certain players, etc). - Thirdly, if a player is sent off or sin binned, if judged by anyone on the panel to be deserving of points (e.g. through aggression, acts of inspiration, etc) he still be eligible for points, unlike that hack system voted for by journo's... - Fourthly, I understand why you want the 5 points, to give the (BHQ) MoM a clear advantage each week, however over a season 3 points is more fair. Quite often there will be a few players who could all very easily be Mom, so it is very harsh for them to receive so fewer points than the voted MoM. - Lastly and IMO most importantly; perhaps two categories "Best Forward" & "Best Back" each week? So often forwards (the real workers and by far the most important players on the field) are over looked in these type of things. Other than a hooker [size=7](Cam Smith is a demi-God)[/size] name me a forward who has won a Dally M? If this is deemed to advanced and one category is simpler, I urge all members who make up the judging to understand the role of forwards in RL! Cheers NNN icon_thumbs_u [/QUOTE]

Verification

Active Now

No members online now.

Total: 5 (members: 0, guests: 5)

Reply to thread

Log in

Active Now