Reply to thread

Message: [QUOTE="Big Pete, post: 3451326, member: 1899"] This is missing some nuance. I believe the Woolford comparison I made goes a long way to explaining the situation. Is Woolford the best dummy half in the competition? No, not even close. Did Woolford make a positive contribution to the Raiders and earn his place in the squad? Absolutely, so did Billy at dummy half. The arguments I've seen is that he was never dropped all season. OK, when did he deserve to be dropped at dummy half? The concensus was that Turpin should not have found his way back into the team, that was the player that should have made way, which is why his name is still being brought up. It's a different conversation entirely, but comments like Paix is 'easily' better than Walters doesn't have a strong basis. There was one game against the Bulldogs where Paix made a big difference, otherwise they just worked well as a tandem with Paix providing fresh legs. Cory is still raw and unfortunately after the Raiders game his season was a write off. Again, Paix finished the season training with the rehab group with a knee brace on. [/QUOTE]

No members online now.

Total: 210 (members: 0, guests: 210)