Reply to thread

Message: [QUOTE="Unbreakable, post: 3090199, member: 8290"] Let's just put this to bed, am I correct in saying that your 2 main gripes with people on here in regards to player criticism is 1) Discussing it in multiple threads / repeating their opinion and 2) Not sharing the blame with other members of the team who under-perform just as much as the likes of Boyd & McCullough (previously Hunt)? In regards to 1) I don't know why you have such a problem with this, if people feel like the performances of [I]any[/I] player on the team warrant discussing in any post-game thread and any discussion thread in the Broncos sub-forum, that's completely up to them, we give people the right to share their opinion as many times as they want, as long as it's not specifically to get a reaction out of people (not naming names, but you know who). In regards to 2) I don't agree with this part. There's no question that the more experienced members of the team are held to a higher calibre of performance, which is why the likes of Boyd & McCullough are the first and foremost to be blamed when things go south. And yes, there's probably been times where they've been blamed even if they weren't in our worst bunch of players. But with that being said, almost everyone on the team gets criticised at different points, Milford has copped it this year more than ever, plenty of people wanted Isaako playing QCUP earlier in the season, TPJ received almost as much criticism as anyone on the team this season because of his discipline and defensive efforts, Oates was copping it left and right post-Origin, nearly everyone has been against Ofahengaue since he re-signed. My opinion is that you're just taking things personal that aren't personal. People are going to continue to criticise the under-performing players until they're either performing at an adequate level or they're no longer on the team, that's part and parcel of being on a Rugby League forum. If you feel that certain players deserve more criticism, criticise them. I think you'll find people would be more receptive to you giving negative feedback on the under-performing players than psuedo-defending players like Boyd & McCullough when they're also under-performing. [/QUOTE]

Verification

Active Now

No members online now.

Total: 4 (members: 0, guests: 4)

Reply to thread

Log in

Active Now