Reply to thread

Message: [QUOTE="Art Vandelay, post: 3100624, member: 8304"] I've probably said this before with regards to TPJ's discipline but I really think calling it a problem is being too outcome oriented. Yes, he received eight weeks of suspension across three charges this year. But he could have easily walked away from the same three infringements without even a penalty against him. His shot on Cronk was less late than his shot on McGuire that didn't attract a penalty. His tackle on Sami was cleaner than Crocker's shot on Brett Stewart in the GF that was ruled legal and the Maloney tackle was just an absolutely horseshit call that should never satisfy the criteria for a crusher tackle. He was crucified for tackling backs as hard as he tackles forwards. Do you think Billy Slater or Thurston would have been penalised for any of those tackles? [/QUOTE]

No members online now.

Total: 9 (members: 0, guests: 9)