Reply to thread

Message: [QUOTE="Sproj, post: 3549968, member: 8423"] Right, here you go: 1. Walsh (2015 Boyd was a seriously good player but while he had the fantastic playmaking and was extremely solid, Walsh is Slater, obvious win to 2023) 2. Oates 2015 (Look Oatesy may not even make it this year with so many injuries, I'd seriously be going Mariner here) 3. Staggs (Man this is a really hard one - 2015 Reed was an absolute gun but Staggs is the best centre in the comp right now, he is absolutely on fire) 4. Hodges (Its Hodges and while he was being held together by sticky tape at that point, he was one of the most gifted centres to ever play the game and this may well just be my nostalgia speaking because Herbie is a gun) 5. Cobbo (Lets be honest, we all forgot Kahu was there in 2015 and while he was solid, he didn't even half the weapons Cobbo does) 6. Milford (Look, this will be controversial and Mam has been phenomenal but I am trying to be objective here and 2015 Milford was electric and he was the best player in the field in the Gf, comfortably and yes, I know this is so hard to believe when looking at what happened to this lazy idiot) 7. Reynolds (Hunt was amazing, he really was but you just cannot look past those GF brain explosions, Reynolds is so calm, composed and is the conductor that makes the orchestra sound so beautiful, he has unlocked the team) 8. Thaiday (Flegler has kind of stagnated somewhat and while Thaiday was well past his best at this point, he still had the ability to have a cracker at that point) 9. Walters (Macca was an excellent clubman but he was limited, very limited and that showed through when he refused to pass to an unmarked Parker who was in under the posts in the GF) 10. Haas (He is a generational talent, seriously and to be fair, I HATED the Blair signing but in 2015, as a prop of all positions, Blair was excellent but he wasn't a patch on Haas) 11. Capewell (Glenn was an extremely solid player in 2015 but Capewell looks to be fit again and he is a weapon in his own right) 12. Gillett (Gillett was one of the best backrowers we've had and Riki may well go down that way too but he isn't even close to what Gillett was doing back then) 13. Can't split it (I genuinely can't and honestly, post-career commentary Parker is awful but as a player at the 2015 point, he was Australian lock and rightly so, he was phenomenal and very much like current Carrigan) 14. Wallace (I love Piaks but he is young and while looking amazing, Wallace stepped up massively in the GF, he was excellent and is still a really good forward in his own right) 15. Hetherington (Actually, these guys are actually pretty comparable because Dodds also hit like a sledge hammer and was in a purple patch in 2015 but Hetherington looks amazing and is the type of no nonsense every premiership winner needs) 16. Taupau (Joffa was really good but at this point in his career, he was a baby and it is an interesting head to head because Taupau is basically the opposite as he is past his best but brings experience to a very exciting young side but that said, I am also not even sure he makes it back in here) 17. Nikorima (Smoothy is solid but Nikorima was at his best as a bench utility and he was a bit of an x factor in 2015) So 10-8 (one split) to 2023. [/QUOTE]

Verification

Active Now

No members online now.

Total: 141 (members: 0, guests: 141)

Reply to thread

Log in

Active Now