Reply to thread

Message: [QUOTE="The True King, post: 3187056, member: 9651"] This is a good idea. Keep the journo's and panel "experts" on Fox/Nine out of influencing the voting and I think we'd get a much fairer outcome. The only real issue with having 3-2-1 voting on both sides is that one or two of the consistent performers (say Haas or Lolo) in poor sides are still going to poll better than the top teams where many players are contributing on a weekly basis (e.g. Cleary and Keary). An alternative could be to get the 16 coaches to do two lists. Firstly, a list of players of the season in each starting position + interchange ("Team of the Year"). Secondly, ranking 1-10 of the best players in the comp for the season, not including finals or origin (Dally M). The only caveat being that the coaches can't nominate any of their own players in either list. If a club is without a coach at the end of the season the respective club captain submits the two lists on the clubs behalf. [/QUOTE]

No members online now.

Total: 14 (members: 0, guests: 14)