Reply to thread

Message: [QUOTE="Anonymous person, post: 2452663, member: 2115"] for someone that "couldn't make the tackle" he sure tackled him well less than half a second before he got the ball. i did read all of the rule - the word WOULD is still the word that points out that it has to be a certainty. with a defender right on top of him, along with only getting the ball 5m+ from the try line, its not a certainty "but for the unfair play of the defender". for mine, to see a great example of how its not a certainty you only need to go back to origin 3 this year. same player too - when smith went straight through, dummied past the fullback, and then passed to inglis, he was in for all money. thurston who was right next to him started jumping up and down in celebration......then inglis got pulled down from behind and lo and behold, didnt make the try line. everyone in the stadium thought inglis was in. thurston thought inglis was in. inglis probably thought inglis was in. inglis wasnt in. im sorry but getting taken out 5m+ from the try line by a tackler who is right on top of you is not a penalty try. [/QUOTE]

No members online now.

Total: 8 (members: 0, guests: 8)