Reply to thread

Message: [QUOTE="Big Pete, post: 3184371, member: 1899"] Well if we didn't have it then all the discussion would be focused on the Rapana try which was proof positive why we need a review system. That's where we disagree. I'm fine with the head high being let go because it's consistent with the rest of the game. There would be so many tackles where there was incidental contact with the head where by the rules their penalties but really they don't deserve to be blown. The referee live was of the opinion it didn't deserve a penalty, Nicoll-Klokstad didn't take his head off and for now I'm fine with it being play on. If the MRC come out tomorrow and decide 'yeah, nah let's charge him' then the Roosters deserve to feel hard done by. Morris' mistake was not reaching the in-goal. It's worth noting that Keary was going to be penalised and Klein just wanted to make sure of it since he wanted to review the restart which he's entitled to do in the in-goal. I agree that the referees need a review in general. They're like the Broncos, brought up under a different administration, expected to adapt to all these systems that go against their instincts with even less support. [/QUOTE]

No members online now.

Total: 4 (members: 0, guests: 4)