Reply to thread

Message: [QUOTE="theshed, post: 3673657, member: 2290"] I’m not fully sold on McGuire, I think he has shown far more upside than Kev over a longer career but there are definite question marks. Kev has his 4 years, he didn’t reach a pass mark. Not even by his own targets. Kev always said not making finals is a failure and he failed 3 out of 4 times. It’s someone else’s turn. Madge might not be the perfect option but what shits me is that he won’t even get a fair go. He’s going to walk in and be treated the same way Seibold was and will be flogged non-stop at every point. One thing he a great job of at Souths is he respected their culture and built on it, and the old boys allowed him to do so. He could do that for us but he won’t be given the chance. I kind of hope we have secretly signed Belly or Wayne by some miracle, purely because all the olds boys sharpening their knives will have to awkwardly shut up and accept it was a good move. I hope Dave has learned a lot from this experience. He got a few things wrong through all this. [/QUOTE]

No members online now.

Total: 5 (members: 0, guests: 5)