Reply to thread

Message: [QUOTE="Burg, post: 2282951, member: 1785"] This is a good thread, but before we decide who we should keep isn't also important to see who is available from other clubs which would greatly influence the outcome. I mean would you keep Simms if say Aiden Tolman, Jeff Lima, Kevin Proctor, Kade Snowden or David Shillington were available for simular money? What about Gerard Beale, Josh Hoffman or Steve Michaels, would you keep them or get the likes of William Zillman, Josh Dugan, Jarrod Croker or Blake Ferguson. How about Ben Te'o, Lagi Setu or Dunamis Lui, would you rather them or Mark Minichiello, Ashley Harrison, Issac Luke, Yileen Gordon, Scott Bolton, Glenn Stewart, Bronson Harrison, Jeremy Smith or Joel Thompson. Ok, these are just a few guys that are going well, most are not big names, just solid first graders in most cases. It’s one thing to say who you should keep and it’s another to know who is available and what they bring to the club. Personally I like Tolman and Snowden and I know that Tolman is out of contract the end of this year. Te’o has been inconsistent and Setu has been worse, comes out of the line too many times to put on a big hit, misses and leaves a gap, would not be upset if he was cut. Simms has only really had a handful of good games, the rest has been forgettable, I think his time is limited if we could find a replacement such as Tolman, I'd be taking it. McGuire has yet to impress but I’m happy enough to give him at least another season, forwards take longer to mature. Beale has not impressed so far, ask me again later in the season, but so far reminds me of Moon and Emmett, has potential but failed to deliver. Michaels has been given too many chances and would be one of the first cut IMO. Parker and Thaiday are a must and Thaiday needs to get back to second row, he is wasted in the front row. The other young players should be retained. I still think that there should be enough money left under the cap to get say Civoniceva, Thronc and Tolman, retain the young players and start looking for a replacement for Lockyer. [/QUOTE]

Verification

Active Now

No members online now.

Total: 3 (members: 0, guests: 3)

Reply to thread

Log in

Active Now