Reply to thread

Message: [QUOTE="Dexter, post: 2454417, member: 1978"] Never said that at all. I've been quite clear, the Guidelines are the refs interpretation of the Laws and they are being interpreted incorrectly in places. As in the Slater dropped ball. I seem to remember you arguing about the knock on rule and saying the rules are the rules and the refs shouldn't be ruling knock on when a player drops the ball backwards from the hands onto to the knee, blah blah blah and 10 pages of APism. If you were in Harrigans spot the knock on Law wouldn't change but your interpretation would and the game would change because of 1 persons point of view. I'm still waiting for you to produce this BoD RULE btw or should it just read BoD see Macquarie Dictionary for definition. You surely can't just refer to a rule and not have a definition. What happens if say Melb are pinned against their tryline and the Dogs pick up a player and drive him back over the tryline in a two man tackle, the ball is dislodged and the dogs place the ball and claim a try. The refs are not sure if it was a strip so they go to the video. Who gets BoD ? Melb who were the attacking side or the Dogs who were defending. What about a charge down and the player who scores was borderline offside. Which team gets BoD. The team which kicked or the team which charged down? You see, rules need definitions otherwise they are not rules just words. [/QUOTE]

No members online now.

Total: 322 (members: 0, guests: 322)