Reply to thread

Message: [QUOTE="theshed, post: 3311988, member: 2290"] You live in a fantasy land. I’m not dismissive of stats, I don’t think tackle efficiency is a good measure of defensive quality. Secondly, I know you like stats which is why I chose to use them. Less game time, if anything, should result in higher average metres per hit up, not less. The difference between the 2 “gorilla’s” tries is that Haas created the opportunity for his with his previous run. A run that only Flegler matched in that game. Again, we are meant to be talking about this game only when choosing the best 3 players, so what Haas did last week is irrelevant and if he didn’t get a mention in the top 3 it would probably be justified. This week was Kennedy’s turn to make the error and it contributed to his below average performance - this week. Posters were critical of Haas for that but if someone always does an amazing job and makes 1 terrible error is it wrong to be less critical of them than of a guy who does the bare minimum a bench prop is expected to do (granted at a bargain price) who makes an equally dumb mistake? I don’t think it is. The mistakes are as bad as each other except Haas’ mistake is wrapped in excellence and Kennedy’s mistake is wrapped in mediocrity. Would you be more critical of Milf making an error than you you would of JT making the same error? I’d hope so. [/QUOTE]

No members online now.

Total: 127 (members: 0, guests: 127)