Reply to thread

Message: [QUOTE="Fozz, post: 3502440, member: 1809"] In terms of the "hip drops" Hopgood: 100% a hip drop on the basis that he had his footing, was dragging back on the tackled player and then lifted his feet to pull them down. Mam: Started out as a low tackle and got dragged along by the tackled player before losing his footing. The key would be whether he deliberately lifted his feet or the momentum of the tackled dragged him along. Personally I feel he was just dragged along and lost his footing because of the momentum not for a hip drop action. Haas: Not a hip drop. He's making a tackle and is slung around. He's not pulling back wards and lifting his feet to drag the player down. Hopgood and Mam won't be charged, I'd say the bins will be considered enough punishment. Haas shouldn't be charged but who knows with the MRC lottery. Badger didn't send down a call to bin him so that's at least one person who agrees it wasn't a hip drop. [/QUOTE]

No members online now.

Total: 13 (members: 0, guests: 13)