Reply to thread

Message: [QUOTE="Anonymous person, post: 2342065, member: 2115"] how could you say the Dally M player of the year, and basically inarguably the best half of the year, doesnt deserve a run in the 4 nations? and how could you say hes not in better FORM than Lockyer? Lockyer hadnt played for what, 8 weeks of footy before the 4 nations? how can you be in good form when you havent played for 3 months? and in that time, Carney was carving up. he doesnt have to be 'the very best' to get a spot in a representative team, he just has to be the best for that spot at the time - and you cant deny that Carney has been the best in that spot for at least the last half of the season and then the finals. yes, he was better than Lockyer, because he played more games and dominated more games than Lockyer. and quite frankly, Lockyer hasnt done anything standout-ish in the 4 nations so far, has he? Carney MORE than deserves a shot IMO. in all likelihood, Carney and Thurston are the Australian halves for the foreseeable future - why not get him started in a dead rubber? who won the Dally M Coach of the Year? Bennett? [/QUOTE]

No members online now.

Total: 296 (members: 0, guests: 296)