Reply to thread

Message: [QUOTE="OXY-351, post: 2342248, member: 2107"] if orford was playing better, yes. im not sayng that just because Carney won the Dally M he should automatically get chosen - as we all know, people have won dally Ms when they shouldnt have. but even disregarding Carneys dally m win, he was in superb form for the second half of the season, much better than Lockyer. if orford was in better form than Thurston for half the season leading up to the tests, then sure, drop Thurston for him. no problems with that from me.[/quote:g1h2ikmz] I'd much rather stick with a proven player at that level (origin, inetrnational), than someone who has had ONE decent season at club level. Don't forget that combinations play a big part in a side too. You'd have to weigh up whether Carney is actually playing THAT much better than Lockyer to warrant upsetting match winning combinations that have been forged over many seasons. Yes, Carney had a good season, but I don't think Lockyer has done anything recently to justify him being replaced in the side. [/QUOTE]

No members online now.

Total: 1 (members: 0, guests: 1)