Reply to thread

Message: [QUOTE="Anonymous person, post: 2382377, member: 2115"] i dont know what argument you think i was wrong in, but going by the actual NRL rules as defined in the actual NRL rules document, a knock-on is: it does not include ANYTHING about knocking the ball forwards with any part of your chest/torso, nor does it mention anything about knocking it back onto your chest/head and then it going forward being a knock-on. it does say but the wording indicates to me that its only illegal if its deliberate. the word "illegal" also indicates that a penalty is the outcome, not a knock-on. if this was the reason for the 'no try' against the broncos after reed went for that catch, it would have been a penalty to the dragons instead of a turnover. they might agree on that, but theyre both wrong. [/QUOTE]

No members online now.

Total: 10 (members: 0, guests: 10)