Reply to thread

Message: [QUOTE="Kimlo, post: 3054080, member: 2021"] The only reason any of those achievements matter is it proves Boyd can actually perform and be a star at the highest level. Macca has not done anything of any note, ever. So the chance of him suddenly doing so 11 years into his career is below zero. He's average-to-crap, always has been, always will be. Probably a fantastic ISC player though but a good first grader he is not. That's why I defend Boyd and not Macca. One has proven performance at the highest level, one does not. What am I going to defend Macca on? The only thing he ever had on his side is that he's young so should get better (lol) and that he doesn't have any real clangers in his game, that's about it. Boyd also has versatility in that he probably could be a very good centre, I even thought he was fantastic at 5/8 although I can't see him offering value there long term. Macca is a 9 and that's it. He really just hurts the team by being in it at all. We can't put him somewhere else, he is in the most important position on the field and murders our attack. FWIW, I'd still take Taylor back if he agreed to a 1 year contract relative to his actual form, AKA about 100-200K and he can prove he deserves a better contract. I won't ever blame Taylor for taking the money, 4 million for 4 years is absurd, he'd be a fool not to bank that but it does mean he doesn't back himself as a long term star IMO. [/QUOTE]

No members online now.

Total: 287 (members: 0, guests: 287)