Reply to thread

Message: [QUOTE="Unbreakable, post: 3300301, member: 8290"] How you can say Cobbo was further along in his career than Mam when he debuted? They're in the same age group, have played for the same junior rep teams together, both debuted in Queensland Cup this season and both have single digit Queensland Cup games to their names (as does Robati). I have no issue with you, or anyone else saying that Mam shouldn't be considered for a debut this season, but some of the reasons being thrown about in this thread are just egregious. Obviously there's technical limitations to his possible debut with the contract & bubble situation, but even putting those to one side, the best we've come up with is "He shouldn't be considered because it's not a natural career trajectory" (Numerous examples of his exact trajectory at the club this season) and "He shouldn't be considered because he might play good and other teams will offer him a contract" (Numerous examples of players being poached from this club within the last 2 years, well before they're debuting at an NRL, or even Queensland Cup level - As well as numerous examples of players who've debuted, played well, and had their contract extended at the club) Like.. what. [/QUOTE]

No members online now.

Total: 17 (members: 0, guests: 17)