Reply to thread

Message: [QUOTE="Fitzy, post: 3611496, member: 9881"] Baker average, very average. Won’t say completely shithouse but just average. Doesn’t belong in a full strength 17 and I’d be picking Te Kura on the bench before him as well. Whilst Payne is out I do think he is the most appropriate to start so no criticism on Kev in that regard for now. Xavier is fucking awesome great game. That’s about as good as I have seen a 10 gamer chuck up 40 minutes. He has looked awesome in both games now after backing up a good pre-season and all-stars. He is the real deal. Cobbo looked dangerous thought it was a relatively good game despite the error or two. Don’t think he was motm at all. Reece was very rough around the edges but he will be better for the game back. Madden leaves a lot to be desired, ALWAYS. Not the guy imo. Staggs had a very good game without being special. Hetho beast. Carrigan MOTM leaps and bounds over the next best crop of players. Arthars not great, don’t think that’s the edge for him imo. Would consider playing Pereira on the right, Arthars left and Oates 17. As you can guess Oates very average. Walters has his moments like always but he has some very painful decisions as well. He is a solid presence defensively and he has his moments. Smoothy always comes on and plays really smoothly (pun intended). Still would keep it like this though. Riki average Hunt think is copping a bit of a tough time. If you gave me these 3 performances as an option 3 weeks ago I would have run off laughing ecstatically. Nothing remotely amazing about his game but I think he has chucked up 2 fairly solid games and a very average game. I don’t ever sit watching the footy concerned about what he is going to do and that’s as much as I could ask for a back up second rower in our current shortage. Ezra pretty good. Last year with Reyno out and Walsh having a poor game I would say it’s impossible for Mam to have had a good game himself but that hasn’t been the case at times this year. Doesn’t need his hand held which is what you want from your young half as he develops. Loved being at the game because I never as intensely analyse and get worked up by things so nowhere near as negative as you lot. I saw a game that had some rusty shit but got me so siked for our full side. [/QUOTE]

Verification

Active Now

No members online now.

Total: 5 (members: 0, guests: 5)

Reply to thread

Log in

Active Now