Reply to thread

Message: [QUOTE="Midean, post: 3617571, member: 10185"] We have seen try's scored, at speed where the player gets the lightest, briefest touch of a finger grazing the ball over the try line and its awarded. Api clearly had more control over the ball than those situations. it is NOT a knock on, as the ball didnt touch the ground, or anything else before he plants it in a controlled fashion with downward pressure and no separation at the point the ball touches the ground. If a knock on only requires separation now, then every single bobble of the ball, regardless of regather needs to be called a knock on, because that is what every one of you is implying. Are you saying he had zero control over the ball when he planted it down with force? did the ball bounce from his hand onto the ground? Or did the ball move, and he reapplied controlled downward force to the ball and plant it? Seriously, how is this even being argued now. No one is denying there was ball movement in the air, there certainly was. But there WAS NO KNOCK ON! THERE WAS CONTROLLED DOWNWARD PRESSURE AND HE PLANTED THE BALL! [/QUOTE]

No members online now.

Total: 240 (members: 0, guests: 240)