Reply to thread

Message: [QUOTE="Midean, post: 3617579, member: 10185"] It's ruining the game imo. At normal speed on any given day that's a try. If you slow it down to 100fps its questionable. Cant stand these rule changes sometimes. Ive literally watched 3 different shows that have reviewed this situation and literally no one agree's on it. Its either a blatant no try, or a ridiculous call. As i said, the 360 panel (not the brightest of sparks but still) where arguing over it. Gus unleashed both barrels on it. And its been blasted by numerous other footy pundits on X and reddit etc etc. I hate that it was given no try, when in my opinion he did enough to score. The ref on field gave it. There was no knock on. He applies controlled downward pressure. If we can score a try by slamming our body/forearm down on a ball (which has considerably less control over the ball than api did slamming it down with his hand) then it should be fine if the ball has movement in the hand, so long as it touches nothing after the fact, and the ball is planted with control. Frustrating NRL. [/QUOTE]

No members online now.

Total: 239 (members: 0, guests: 239)