Reply to thread

Message: [QUOTE="john1420, post: 2830983, member: 2077"] As to the Wallace no-try decision..... The moment it happened I said to my son, if that exact thing happens anywhere else on the field it is called knock-on, so it's the right call The exact same thing did happen later in the game, and in other games over the weekend, and ALL of them called knock on, and nobody claimed they were wrong The rules don't change just because you're over the line instead of mid-field You can argue if you want that the ball doesn't really go forward if it's knocked out that way, but the way the rule has been interpreted for as long as I can remember is knock on So argue the rule is wrong, or argue the interpretation of the rule is wrong, but the way the game has been reffed in recent memory that call was spot on [/QUOTE]

No members online now.

Total: 310 (members: 0, guests: 310)