Reply to thread

Message: [QUOTE="john1420, post: 3083945, member: 2077"] Oh, of course there is an argument.........it just might not be a good one ;) Also bear in mind I said arguably, by which I mean I can argue for it, but I am not convinced either way - IMO you can make a case each way So, here goes :) A lot of what Smith has achieved has an asterisk next to it, in fairness the same for Cronk The 2 of them spent most of their time together in; 1) an illegal team whose achievements should not be recognised 2) a once in a lifetime Origin team, chock full of other superstars, not just them Smith's (and Cronk's) participation in the greatest winning run and domination in Origin history makes them part of the most dominant Origin team, not the individual reason for it (a big part yes of course) If we judge them just on this so far, they are both exceptional but Smith does come out in front But then 2018 happens, and Cronk and Smith find themselves on the opposite side of the field for the first time, and what happens? The roosters dispatch the storm both years to take the premiership Cronk took it to Smith and beat him So that's an argument to have him in there ahead of Smith, but it's not definitive, just an argument [/QUOTE]

No members online now.

Total: 63 (members: 0, guests: 63)