Reply to thread

Message: [QUOTE="Lockysillegitimatechild, post: 2955959, member: 8814"] I actually completly agree with that side for next year except for wallace, like i said, i believe whether he is the best option or not has become irrelevant purely because a message needs to be sent to other players “you cant play like that in our jersey on multiple occaissons, particularly after talking it up” its ben creagh level pea heartedness I especially agree with the milford in for taylor if he continues to lack consistency and doesnt grow his game. The other point is oates, agree that he probably gets hard done by again next year no matter his form but the question is why? Walters dug his own grave here (surely you cant say this wasnt his decision? He publicly praised holmes dozens of times, hes a favourite of his). Holmes and gagai need to stuff up to not get selected, why wasnt oates given this same latitude that so many others are currently getting? He gives our team so much more then a standard winger. He shoudlnt have ever been dropped and this shouldnt even be a debate, the fact he has been dropped and its debatable a year later speaks volumes. If we won last year with oates in the team would there be a debate going on this year about his spot on the side? I doubt it, itd at least be a lot less You may disagree with the boyd and thaiday selections, but my question is, would bennett or meninga d what walters did? The answer is no, a big no. Origin isnt nrl, experience (20+ games) beats outsolid nrl form 99% of the time. Cooper has done nothing wrong... just like boyd, thaiday and scott. Yet the reason they got dropped was age and form. So why isnt cooper? “Because we have better options”... so wallace played better then scott or thaiday eould have in ANY of his prigin games? No way he has I also thought about segeyaro but only as a bench utility Ive got no doubt the selection panel had a say, but its his team. After 2 series wins there is no doubt he would have got the final say, and if he didnt that says more about him then if he did! I dont want someone that weak in making decisions to run my club! And if he did, they are terrible, its honestly lose-lose in my eyes because one speaks about his character and strength to coach the broncos, the other about his decision making. Whether he listened to them or not is irrellevant really. He deserves the criticism, that doesnt mean to say the selection panel dont either. [/QUOTE]

Verification

Active Now

No members online now.

Total: 161 (members: 0, guests: 161)

Reply to thread

Log in

Active Now