Reply to thread

Message: [QUOTE="Big Pete, post: 2344922, member: 1899"] You're probably right it appears I'm in the minority with this issue. Final say before we continue roasting Sheens. I disagree with the principle that players should be rated on a scale, to me it's not a fair way to give certain players their due and it doesn't paint the picture of the game correctly. Let's say for instance Josh Hoffman, now I reckon Josh Hoffman had a good if not great season but would arguably be just outside the top 5 for fullbacks in 2010. Does that undermine Josh's good work? Hell no, I still think Josh had a good if not great season and would be happy to honour it. Same with Hornby, I personally thought he did a good job of leading the Dragons pack around and giving the likes of Boyd and Soward room to move. Now if we're talking about positional awards it's totally different, there's definitely a scale there and I think there's proof of that when a player like Scott Prince can win an award while players like Rogers, Friend and Bailey not being recognised despite arguably having better seasons than their team mate. That's enough out of me, critique me all you want. [/QUOTE]

No members online now.

Total: 103 (members: 0, guests: 103)