Reply to thread

Message: [QUOTE="Lockysillegitimatechild, post: 2869853, member: 8814"] I agree with you on this and I think Bellamy has been good for their careers. I also don't often deal in hypotheticals, but what you have to wonder is: smith would be a great without Bellamy, but would Bellamy have won a premiership without smith? Whereas Bennett has and can win premierships without immortals in his team. Slater also would have had a good career, Cronk I think he can take a lot of credit for. I, as a broncos fan, also get frustrated when people say "but you have all these great players in your team" when they started their careers there though and that isn't my argument at all... For me it isn't that he has those players and they make him a good coach, it's more then Bennett has coached all different types of teams with different players in different situations, Bellamy went out of that environment once (origin) and got smashed. I'm not saying he couldn't, I'm saying why compare him to someone who has achieved that and a lot more over a longer period... I'm not doubting Bellamy is a good coach, but he is no where near Bennett. He'd have to win another 3 premierships, have his cheating years be vanished from my memory while having the premierships included and win 4 state of origin series to have a positive record in the arena before I even considered it... [/QUOTE]

No members online now.

Total: 3 (members: 0, guests: 3)