Reply to thread

Message: [QUOTE="Kimlo, post: 2937218, member: 2021"] Sure, if we were to judge Bennett by ONLY the 90's, he wouldn't be a GOAT coach. That's exactly my point? It looks like you're reaching to argue a point I'm not even making. I have not said Bellamy is a shit coach, I said he's probably an excellent coach, but until he does it with different squads at the very least, he can't be spoken about in the same discussion as Bennett. That's just cold hard facts, there is really nothing to argue there. Bennett has more premierships. Bennett has had premierships under different spines. Bennett has had premierships under totally different NRL eras. Bennett has had premierships with different clubs, including an entirely different team, coaching staff, and culture. Bennett has had success at both International and SOO levels. Like they are so far apart from being compared it's not even funny. Bellamy has proven nothing except that if he has a really good spine, he can get the best out of them. He has proven nothing beyond that, at any level of the game, and he arguably would have lost that spine he put together if he didn't cheat the cap. Smith was seriously considering going to the Titans when they put a huge offer in for him, but surprise surprise he stayed for an even bigger offer at Melbourne. How can you even make the argument that Bellamy is more adaptable when ALL the evidence points to Bennett not only being more successful, but doing it across a far broader spectrum of variables. [/QUOTE]

Verification

Active Now

No members online now.

Total: 82 (members: 0, guests: 82)

Reply to thread

Log in

Active Now