Awards

winslow_wong said:
Rigged. When your dad is head coach
Click to expand...
I'm just as perplexed as to why Boyd got best back over Roberts, or even Oates who I think improved this year when he was not injured. But I doubt our own awards are rigged against our own players, that's tin foil hatting to the extreme...

Macca played well in his 18 games and wouldn't have thought it was weird he got it if he played the whole year, but he didn't play that well that McGuire or Gillett wouldn't have overtaken him with the extra games they played.

Also, Glenn was consistent... but McGuire was consistently better. Doesn't the standard matter with the "most consistent" award?

And finally, why the hell don't the finals games count? I can understand that for the dally m's as half the players don't get the chance to play in them, but all these guys get the same opportunity. I don't understand that at all...
 
Lockysillegitimatechild said:
I'm just as perplexed as to why Boyd got best back over Roberts, or even Oates who I think improved this year when he was not injured. But I doubt our own awards are rigged against our own players, that's tin foil hatting to the extreme...

Macca played well in his 18 games and wouldn't have thought it was weird he got it if he played the whole year, but he didn't play that well that McGuire or Gillett wouldn't have overtaken him with the extra games they played.

Also, Glenn was consistent... but McGuire was consistently better. Doesn't the standard matter with the "most consistent" award?

And finally, why the hell don't the finals games count? I can understand that for the dally m's as half the players don't get the chance to play in them, but all these guys get the same opportunity. I don't understand that at all...
Click to expand...

The worry is now that Boyd got best back does he also get that pay rise?
 
Even I was surprised Macca won the Paul Morgan award. But I guess it goes to show he is well-and-truly underrated on this forum. He had an outstanding season.
 
Taylor1921 said:
Put you agenda aside, and look at the stats mate.
Click to expand...
haha I have no agenda against Mccullough. He is actually my favourite player and will be till he retires or leaves. Loved him since his debut. So no agenda.
If you think about it no one was really better than him, no player made any real headlines for the Broncos so it is a fair call.
 
Players' player is normally a good judge, McCullough was ranked by the other players the best so winning the player of the year isn't a stretch.

Same with Boyd, highest ranked back in player of the year so not hard to win best back.
 
1910 said:
Players' player is normally a good judge, McCullough was ranked by the other players the best so winning the player of the year isn't a stretch.

Same with Boyd, highest ranked back in player of the year so not hard to win best back.
Click to expand...
Does the coach vote as well?
 
New Posts

Unread

Active Now

No members online now.
Total: 4 (members: 0, guests: 4)
Top