Bennett not to return - Signs with Knights
- Thread starter kluppy
- Start date
Anonymous person
Banned User
- Dec 16, 2008
- 4,635
- 932
Re: is the master coming home
up until 2002 or so, i thought wayne bennett was the best coach around, and would tell anyone who asked as much. since then, no, i dont think he has been the best coach. most reputable people/publications actually agree with me. ricky stuart got to a few grand finals in a row, with a victory. murray took the cowboys to a grand final. sheens took the tigers to a premiership. lang got penrith a premiership. bellamy got 2 premierships, 2 or 3 minor premierships, and rarely did his team lose 2 matches in a row. henjak took a team with no chance to within a game of the grand final.
st george winning a premiership doesnt make him once again the best coach in the game. like ive said, take a look at his team and then take a look at the roosters team of 2010 - the roosters coach did a much better job getting them where they were IMO. yes, Bennett did a good job with them, and yes hes still the greatest coach to date. but that doesnt mean hes the best at the moment.
and yes, the second i read mals post i thought 'well that woudlve gotten me a ban or at least a warning'. but hey, i know that when it comes to bashing me its pretty much no rules apply.
mals post was also completely ridiculous.Big Pete said:
up until 2002 or so, i thought wayne bennett was the best coach around, and would tell anyone who asked as much. since then, no, i dont think he has been the best coach. most reputable people/publications actually agree with me. ricky stuart got to a few grand finals in a row, with a victory. murray took the cowboys to a grand final. sheens took the tigers to a premiership. lang got penrith a premiership. bellamy got 2 premierships, 2 or 3 minor premierships, and rarely did his team lose 2 matches in a row. henjak took a team with no chance to within a game of the grand final.
st george winning a premiership doesnt make him once again the best coach in the game. like ive said, take a look at his team and then take a look at the roosters team of 2010 - the roosters coach did a much better job getting them where they were IMO. yes, Bennett did a good job with them, and yes hes still the greatest coach to date. but that doesnt mean hes the best at the moment.
and yes, the second i read mals post i thought 'well that woudlve gotten me a ban or at least a warning'. but hey, i know that when it comes to bashing me its pretty much no rules apply.
Anonymous person
Banned User
- Dec 16, 2008
- 4,635
- 932
Re: is the master coming home
so when Bellamy won it in 2009 they actually meant to give it to Wayne Bennett, did they? same with Hasler in 2008?
WB is the only person to have won it twice, but really, im not seeing how he couldve won it in 2005. the broncos got thumped in successive finals rounds and got eliminated without winning a match. then he coached the Aussies in the tri nations, which they got smashed 24-0 in the final and were the first australian team to lose an international tournament in 27 years. wow, great year wayne!
but hey, the broncos were on top of the ladder for half the season, that counts for something?
and the RLIF also said that billy slater was the best player in the world in 2008, and we all know that he wasnt, right guys?
so Wayne Bennett has won the RLIF award of best coach every year?Big Pete said:
so when Bellamy won it in 2009 they actually meant to give it to Wayne Bennett, did they? same with Hasler in 2008?
WB is the only person to have won it twice, but really, im not seeing how he couldve won it in 2005. the broncos got thumped in successive finals rounds and got eliminated without winning a match. then he coached the Aussies in the tri nations, which they got smashed 24-0 in the final and were the first australian team to lose an international tournament in 27 years. wow, great year wayne!
but hey, the broncos were on top of the ladder for half the season, that counts for something?
and the RLIF also said that billy slater was the best player in the world in 2008, and we all know that he wasnt, right guys?
Re: is the master coming home
My post was in no way shape or form a reflection of your opinion on Wayne. How would I know what you thought of Wayne in 2002? No less 1983! I think you missed the whole gist of the post. I was basically trying to convey how I believe you act in ALL opinions you put forward on this forum. Which is a pain in my ass to read. It grows tiresome as majority on here would agree. (after reading your post above I think you've proved my point.)
But I'll stop there as I don't want to venture too far off topic which I clearly already have done. :oops:
My post was in no way shape or form a reflection of your opinion on Wayne. How would I know what you thought of Wayne in 2002? No less 1983! I think you missed the whole gist of the post. I was basically trying to convey how I believe you act in ALL opinions you put forward on this forum. Which is a pain in my ass to read. It grows tiresome as majority on here would agree. (after reading your post above I think you've proved my point.)
But I'll stop there as I don't want to venture too far off topic which I clearly already have done. :oops:
- Mar 5, 2008
- 55,057
- 35,621
Re: is the master coming home
Personal battle off to PM thanks guys.
If this thread doesn't stop going in the circle it's been going in for about 8 pages now, it will be closed. The WB debate has been done to death, again, and again, and again. Give up.
Personal battle off to PM thanks guys.
If this thread doesn't stop going in the circle it's been going in for about 8 pages now, it will be closed. The WB debate has been done to death, again, and again, and again. Give up.
Big Pete
International Captain
- Mar 12, 2008
- 32,207
- 25,950
Re: is the master coming home
I never said that just pointing out he's the reigning coach of the year.
I'll leave it there, so don't worry mods I'm not about to turn this into Bennettmania XXVIII. AP, unlike a few posters I have time for you and generally think you back up a lot of your arguments with a lot of informed insight. We may of had our share of run it's in the past, but my reaction to mal's post wasn't personal. Just wanted to make that clear.
I never said that just pointing out he's the reigning coach of the year.
I'll leave it there, so don't worry mods I'm not about to turn this into Bennettmania XXVIII. AP, unlike a few posters I have time for you and generally think you back up a lot of your arguments with a lot of informed insight. We may of had our share of run it's in the past, but my reaction to mal's post wasn't personal. Just wanted to make that clear.
Black Philip
State of Origin Captain
- Mar 5, 2008
- 9,600
- 1,305
Re: is the master coming home
WB to AFL? :shock:
draggx said:
WB to AFL? :shock:
Re: is the master coming home
I'm sure you are - my comment wasn't actually directed at the admins, more any other member who bitches and moans about AP but say nothing when someone else posts something along similar type of lines as those AP likes to use to stir people up. But whatever
Nashy said:
I'm sure you are - my comment wasn't actually directed at the admins, more any other member who bitches and moans about AP but say nothing when someone else posts something along similar type of lines as those AP likes to use to stir people up. But whatever
