Top 50 Players of 2016

[Bucking Beads]

Cronk should be number 3 easily. That article is an obvious shitpost from Rothfield to generate discussion.



He might not be top 50 players yet but I don't think Napa is overrated at all. He's definitely one of the best young props in the game.

You've convinced me that he is overrated.

 

[Black Philip]

You've convinced me that he is overrated.

He's only 23, consistently makes 25+ tackles / 120+ meters a game and knows how to put a good shot on. I can't really speak for errors but from what I've seen it's not something he is prone to. He'll most likely be a regular for Queensland and Australia in the future.

What makes you think he is overrated?

 

[Bucking Beads]

I've never seen much from him that made think gee this guys good. Sure he puts on the odd big hit and works reasonably hard but he loves to give away penalties too. I think QLD can do better if requiring a young forward.

 

[Black Philip]

I've never seen much from him that made think gee this guys good. Sure he puts on the odd big hit and works reasonably hard but he loves to give away penalties too. I think QLD can do better if requiring a young forward.

Discipline will come with age. I suppose this is an agree to disagree situation but I see him and McGuire as the future starters for QLDs front row. And IMO they will boss it too.

 

[Black Philip]

Speaking of McGuire, he should be on this list too.

 

[Bucking Beads]

Speaking of McGuire, he should be on this list too.

Well ahead of Napa on the list if this list was fairdinkum. It just shows how little of an idea Rothfield has.

 

[abashii]

Sam Burgess having had a year off is still apparently the 4th best player in the league. Slothfield creates these lists purely to get a reaction on his blog. I'd be surprised if this is his actual top 50, I doubt he can count that high.

Sure he can, it's just 2 cartons and 2 stubbies. That probably explains the quality of his list too now that I think of it.