Who replaces Smith?
- Thread starter Big Pete
- Start date
broncos4life
International Captain
- Oct 5, 2011
- 26,595
- 27,251
Andrew McCullough.
- May 21, 2013
- 19,705
- 20,981
At this stage probably Jake Friend in 2018/19 (Whenever Smith retires), but a LOT can change in 3 years, someone we may not have even heard of could step up and be the best Hooker in Queensland by that time.
broncos4life
International Captain
- Oct 5, 2011
- 26,595
- 27,251
Because his service and defence is the best out of those players, especially out of the hookers that could play 80 minutes.
- Feb 27, 2010
- 29,871
- 12,197
At this point, I think Friend and Macca would be the guys I would trust most to handle the Origin arena. The other have more skill without a doubt, but are more utilitarian players at this stage. This could well change in the future, especially if they become more consistent and prove capable of handling the initial onslaught.
With Smith we don't need it, but I think we will need to go with a bench hooker when he retires.
With Smith we don't need it, but I think we will need to go with a bench hooker when he retires.
Big Pete
International Captain
- Mar 12, 2008
- 32,207
- 25,950
- Thread starter
- #7
What do you make of McCullough's choices from dummy half? Do you think he picks the best times to run the ball? Do you think he organises the forwards effectively? Does he give the ball to the half at the right time?
You would have to think of all those players he's the closest to winning another premiership. I wonder what bearing that will have? Both Granville and Friend played starring roles in the biggest game of the year for their side and Friend was great in a leadership role on Friday...
You would have to think of all those players he's the closest to winning another premiership. I wonder what bearing that will have? Both Granville and Friend played starring roles in the biggest game of the year for their side and Friend was great in a leadership role on Friday...
Clintos
State of Origin Rep
- Apr 8, 2008
- 6,085
- 1,842
Friend/Macca to start with Segeyaro on the bench IMO.
Friend and Macca have the defensive ability to withstand the early origin onslaught and Segeyaro is the perfect player to come off the bench and zip around all those tired forwards.
Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk
Friend and Macca have the defensive ability to withstand the early origin onslaught and Segeyaro is the perfect player to come off the bench and zip around all those tired forwards.
Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk
- Feb 27, 2010
- 29,871
- 12,197
I think Granville and Parcell are also quite capable of playing that role. In fact, at this point I would probably just give it to Granville.
- Apr 26, 2008
- 34,578
- 35,550
If Granville keeps form, he'd have to be in contention for the bench role, I don't think we'll have run with one hooker when Smith retires.
As for first choice, I don't think anyone has a lock on it, it's about who performs the best in the next 2-3 years. I think Friend would make a good go of it, or even Parcell if he really steps up in the next few years and asserts himself as a class hooker.
As for first choice, I don't think anyone has a lock on it, it's about who performs the best in the next 2-3 years. I think Friend would make a good go of it, or even Parcell if he really steps up in the next few years and asserts himself as a class hooker.
- Oct 17, 2013
- 12,841
- 14,848
McCullough has well overtaken Friend and Segeyaro has done nothing over the last year and a bit to warrant being involved in Origin conversation. So if we were picking the team today without Smith, Macca should absolutely be locked in. None of them should play unless there are a few injuries this year.
broncoboy
QCup Player
- Oct 15, 2015
- 550
- 56
jake friend for sure he is an absolute gun and a class player, as well as being a tackling machine hsi kicking out of dummy half and his organisation is first class
in order i would have
1. jake friend
2. jake granville
3. james segeyaro
4. matt parcel
5. andrew McCullough
in order i would have
1. jake friend
2. jake granville
3. james segeyaro
4. matt parcel
5. andrew McCullough
Bucking Beads
International Captain
- Mar 5, 2008
- 24,604
- 7,906
Am I really seeing McCullough get named here??
broncos4life
International Captain
- Oct 5, 2011
- 26,595
- 27,251
Oh come on, you can't be serious.
Battler
State of Origin Rep
- Dec 4, 2013
- 7,179
- 7,065
Friend is overrated imo, but it's between him and McCullough. Granville is great for about 40 minutes total, but you need a bloke who can play 80 and get through work in defense in Origin - I'd pick Seg over him on the bench, which is (should be) his only position in the side.
