Who was better?

You sure picked a toughie for me. Maloney because he adds more in attack and is underrated as a half, while Pearce is overrated by some members of the media and former players, he is just a first-grader nothing more.
 
Sterlo. He's not a total fwit and he didn't play for Manly even if he did play for NSW.

Dane Gagai or Dale Copley?
 
Copley for his slow, but constant improvement, and not being a dickhead! Although Gagai may overtake him in the future...

Alex Glenn or Shaun Berrigan?
 
Berrigan. Both are versatile, but Berrigan managed to be nearly as effective no matter where you put him. Glenn I think is now a specialist back rower.

Leon Bott or Denan Kemp
 
Kemp because 2008. (or maybe 2007 if I have my years confused.)
 
Buderus. He made Andrew Johns look good. As great as I think Priddis was, especially for the Broncos and Panthers, Buderus had a slight edge in skill.

Chris Johns or Josh Morris
 
Johns. He was a complete centre - Morris is good with the ball in his hands and not much else

Tolsen Tollett or Stu Galbraith?
 
Both played halfback for parramatta in the 90's. Galbraith was the half when they beat us in the first game at ANZ
 
Well moving on, Thaiday Vs Glenn
 
At this point in their careers, Thaiday. But I suspect Glenn will be a better, more complete player when we analyse them both post-retirement.

Terry Lamb or Geoff Toovey?
 
ET, more versatile player who was good in all grades. Renouf was a great attacking centre, but like Jennings if he wasn't fed good ball he could be MIA.

Ikin or Wallace
 
Ikin. Was a far better allround player and could play more than 1 position. Shane Webcke v Glenn Lazarus
 
New Posts

Unread

Active Now

No members online now.
Total: 14 (members: 0, guests: 14)
Top