Who has been worse than Maranta?

What's does 100 minus 1 equal? 101?

He needs to be in the in goal area to be a chance of scoring so yeah 101 metres. Give him that push back buffer
 
Last edited:
He needs to be in the in goal area to be a chance of scoring so yeah 101 metres. Give him that push back buffer

Oh sorry, I thought I was responding to someone who said to name one moment of individual brilliance from Maranta in his whole career and I did that.
 
just out of curiousity, is he actually a winger or is he playing out of position and is a fullback?
 
Greg Eden has been horrible in my books, getting carried out, and knock ons and lots more , SEND HIM BACK TO THE SUPER LEAGUE!.
 
Eden's biggest problem is his inability to not get pushed back 5 metres every time he returns a kick or takes a hit up....it is the most frustrating thing to watch. I think a lot of it has to do with where his centre of gravity is when he hits the line. Maranta can atleast make a metre when he hits the line.
 
Eden's biggest problem is his inability to not get pushed back 5 metres every time he returns a kick or takes a hit up....it is the most frustrating thing to watch. I think a lot of it has to do with where his centre of gravity is when he hits the line. Maranta can atleast make a metre when he hits the line.

Gagai was exactly the same when he started in the NRL. He was constantly told to put on size to handle it better. Gagai looks to have a bigger frame and was still growing at the time. Eden doesn't have that luxury. He could probably have worked on footwork and body positioning.
 
I'm starting to think Eden is the super league version of maranta.
 
Both Maranta and Eden are better fullbacks than wingers. I really hoped Eden would stick around in the NRL and end up at the Knights under Nathan Brown. I have no doubt under a coach familiar with his abilities, he would of gotten the best out of him, and we'd all see a completely different player.As for Maranta, he just looks so uncomfortable on the wing. I want to see him come off his wing and rove around a bit like a fullback, just to see what he can do in a more familiar sort of role for him. Maybe that will get him out of his shell a bit more.
 
Both Maranta and Eden are better fullbacks than wingers. I really hoped Eden would stick around in the NRL and end up at the Knights under Nathan Brown. I have no doubt under a coach familiar with his abilities, he would of gotten the best out of him, and we'd all see a completely different player.As for Maranta, he just looks so uncomfortable on the wing. I want to see him come off his wing and rove around a bit like a fullback, just to see what he can do in a more familiar sort of role for him. Maybe that will get him out of his shell a bit more.
What's there to get familiar with? No coach can work with a player who makes negative metres.
 
Both Maranta and Eden are better fullbacks than wingers. I really hoped Eden would stick around in the NRL and end up at the Knights under Nathan Brown. I have no doubt under a coach familiar with his abilities, he would of gotten the best out of him, and we'd all see a completely different player.As for Maranta, he just looks so uncomfortable on the wing. I want to see him come off his wing and rove around a bit like a fullback, just to see what he can do in a more familiar sort of role for him. Maybe that will get him out of his shell a bit more.

I think there was a game last year where Maranta played fullback, and he really did look much more confident in himself. I'm pretty sure he set up a try with some nice support play too. Also, Eden looked infinitely better at fullback in the trial match, albeit against a second string Cowboys side. He scored a couple and set up a couple more with good cutout passes.
 
Two weeks ago would anyone have thought Oates name would be thrown into the discussion? That half is just as bad, if not worse than any half Maranta has given us..
 

Active Now

No members online now.
Top