This is a really hard choice for me... I would try hard to keep them all but if one had to go then it would be Winterstein.
Yow Yeh has potential to be the best in a few years but at the moment he has been average and hasn't been able to perform without Hodgo inside of him. He has great leaping ability and can do those freakish things, but his defence and the fact that he goes into his shell when he isn't outside Hodgo is a worry.
Kemp has been really unlucky since going over to NZ. If he can get back onto the field and get some confidence back then I think he will be able to regain that form. The fact that he lost a lot of confidence and was mistreated in NZ and that he has been injured all this year really worries me though and I think I could be taking a bit of a risk with him. I do think that Kemp is the best defensive winger of the 3 though and is solid under the high ball.
Winterstein is a solid player, but not fantastic. He will do what is needed and is a great finisher (as shown in 2009 when we had KHunt) but just doesn't have the classiness of Yow Yeh or that amazing finishing ability of Kemp. Plus his defence is pretty bad as well as his bomb taking ability, although I think he has improved under the high ball lately. One thing I must say about Winterstein though is he brings the ball back with purpose. Hunt taught him a thing or two about bringing the ball back with impact before he left and it cleary shows (trampling Heremaia against the Warriors etc).
It hurts me to say, but I would let go of Winterstein.
Yow Yeh has potential to be the best in a few years but at the moment he has been average and hasn't been able to perform without Hodgo inside of him. He has great leaping ability and can do those freakish things, but his defence and the fact that he goes into his shell when he isn't outside Hodgo is a worry.
Kemp has been really unlucky since going over to NZ. If he can get back onto the field and get some confidence back then I think he will be able to regain that form. The fact that he lost a lot of confidence and was mistreated in NZ and that he has been injured all this year really worries me though and I think I could be taking a bit of a risk with him. I do think that Kemp is the best defensive winger of the 3 though and is solid under the high ball.
Winterstein is a solid player, but not fantastic. He will do what is needed and is a great finisher (as shown in 2009 when we had KHunt) but just doesn't have the classiness of Yow Yeh or that amazing finishing ability of Kemp. Plus his defence is pretty bad as well as his bomb taking ability, although I think he has improved under the high ball lately. One thing I must say about Winterstein though is he brings the ball back with purpose. Hunt taught him a thing or two about bringing the ball back with impact before he left and it cleary shows (trampling Heremaia against the Warriors etc).
It hurts me to say, but I would let go of Winterstein.
